
"There's no way I can go play for the Yankees, but I know they are going to come after me hard,' Damon said. 'It's definitely not the most important thing to go out there for the top dollar, which the Yankees are going to offer me. It's not what I need.'" -- 05.01.05, Alan Eskew, MLB.com
Predictably, Johnny Damon agreed to a 4 year/$52 million deal with the Yankees on Tuesday night.
(link)
I won't miss JD the person, the media whore, the guy who very publicly treated his ex-wife like shit, the guy who wrote a crappy book just for another payday, the guy who attracted pink-shirt wearing sorority girls to the ballpark, the guy who I was completely sick of hearing about by August.
I won't miss JD the outfielder, who throws as well as my aunt Judy, who clanged against the monster in the ugliest of ways, never seeming to come up with the ball, and who is only getting older and less athletic.
I will, however, miss JD the leadoff hitter. He will be tough to replace.
In pure baseball terms, I don't think this is a terrible move for the Red Sox. Yes, it will hurt them, and help the Yankees, in 2006. The Sox lost an excellent leadoff hitter, the guy whom their offense depended on for much of the season, and the Yankees lineup just got a lot tougher. But there's still time for the Sox to find a replacement, and should they lock up a young guy like Reed or Crisp, as is being suggested, this move suddenly becomes a lot less devastating in terms of next season. Still, one can't argue that offensively speaking, something will be missing.
Look a couple of years into the future, though, and Sox fans will most likely be relieved the club isn't dishing out $13 million to an aging center fielder with a noodle arm, limited range, and diminishing strength. If the Yankees don't plan on using Damon as a DH in the last couple years of that contract, Yankee fans will rue the day this deal was signed. Defensively speaking, Damon is no better than Bernie Williams, the guy the Yankees were so desperate to replace. Sure, he'll hit well in Yankee Stadium as he always has, but if his rapid offensive decline of 2005 is any sign of what's to come, the Red Sox did the right thing by letting him walk.
What's tough to swallow, though, is the fact that Damon did exactly what he said he wouldn't and signed with the Yankees, of all teams. As fans, we sometimes expect more of our athletes than we should, and while I never thought for a minute that he'd stay with Boston for a hometown discount or that he'd turn down a huge payday, it's disappointing to see that all of his comments over the last couple of years were just positioning statements (such as when he referred to the Yankees as "the Devil" after A-Rod signed in NY). And now, as he leaves the city where he was once worshipped, he feels the need to save face, and does so by slinging mud at the Sox front office, claiming a lack of respect and a failure to make a fair offer.
Seth Joyner, a former Eagle, was called by the hated Dallas Cowboys in the middle of his career when it was clear the Eagles did not plan on resigning him. "We want you to sign with us," they told him. His reponse? "I was an Eagle - I could never be a Cowboy." Joyner went on to play for a handful of other teams, but is still, to this day, beloved in Philadelphia.
Johnny Damon, on the other hand, shouldn't expect such reverential treatment in Boston. Just as he doesn't feel he owes the Sox fans anything, we shouldn't feel that we owe him anything, either. Of course, we'll always be thankful for the grand slam in game 7 of the ALCS, and for everything he did in the world series. Despite that, he will be booed lustily each and every time he returns to Fenway. Parents will have to explain to their children why their favorite player is now the enemy. It's a difficult dilemma for Red Sox fans; do you boo the guy who helped bring a world series parade to Boston, or do you cheer a Yankee?
Over in the Bronx, things are not as celebratory as one might expect. The signing has not been well received by Yankee fans, and should Damon fail to live up to his expensive contract, he could find himself in a position he's unfamiliar with - the recipient of boos in his own ballpark. Should he fail to be the centerfielder Yankee brass hopes he will be, he could find himself suddenly alienated by the two largest fanbases in the MLB.
Of course, should Johnny Damon be exposed over the next couple of years as an aging centerfielder whose best days are behind him, Red Sox fans may be able to find it in their hearts to forgive him.


